Is success in fantasy sports based on skill or luck? Here’s what the research says

Research from MIT suggests that fantasy football success may have more to do with skill than luck.

Fantasy sports, especially the ever-popular fantasy football, have captivated armchair sports enthusiasts for years. Drawing upon new research from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), we can now affirm that your triumph in the virtual league tables is more a testament to your strategic acumen than the whims of chance. Whether you’re lounging on your couch or immersed in intense debate at the pub, your performance in these fantasy leagues showcases your tactical prowess rather than mere luck.

A quantitative scrutiny: Evidence of skill

The study spearheaded by Anette “Peko” Hosoi, Associate Dean of Engineering at MIT, doesn’t pin down any particular traits that might distinguish a skilled fantasy player from an amateur. Instead, it demonstrates that the win/loss records of thousands of fantasy players across multiple seasons invariably reflect their skill.

Digging deeper into the skill sets involved, Hosoi elaborates, “Some [fantasy] players may know more about statistics, rules of the game, which players are injured, effects of weather, and a host of other factors that make them better at picking players — that’s the skill in fantasy sports. Does that skill have an impact on the outcome of the [fantasy] game? In our analysis, the signal for skill in the data is very clear.”

Other fantasy sports, such as baseball, basketball, and hockey, also reflect a similar pattern, demonstrating a higher degree of skill compared to activities rooted in pure chance, like coin-flipping. This paves the way for a broader discussion about the nature and role of skill in fantasy sports.

Fantasy sports: An exercise in skill, not gambling

The issue of whether fantasy sports constitute a form of online gambling has been simmering for some time now. FanDuel, the second-largest company in the daily fantasy sports industry, sought to clarify the question, inviting Hosoi and her team to discern whether their contests rewarded skill or chance.

This is a significant question because the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act exempts fantasy sports as they are not seen as a form of betting or wagering. Yet, with the rising popularity and visibility of fantasy sports, several states have begun to question their legal status. Establishing that fantasy sports are more a contest of skill than chance would exempt them from being classified as gambling.

The world of fantasy sports has often found itself intertwined with bookmaking and betting platforms. Many players keen on exploring new platforms or unable to access their favourite fantasy sports platforms due to geographic restrictions often use bookmakers’ alternative links linkalternative.bet. These serve as a useful tool for accessing their preferred fantasy sports and betting platforms, extending their reach and accessibility.

The intricate tests: Quantifying skill and chance

The research team meticulously analysed daily fantasy competitions from 2013 and 2014 seasons, covering baseball, basketball, hockey, and football. They put to test two hypotheses: firstly, if the game was more skill-based, a player’s performance would be persistent across multiple rounds. Secondly, if a game was based on chance, every player should have the same expected outcome, similar to a coin toss.

Through a series of complex calculations and representations, the researchers concluded that all fantasy sports were primarily skill-based. The win fraction of players remained consistent across the first and second halves of the season, proving that individual performance and skill significantly impacted the outcome of fantasy games.

Bridging fantasy and reality: Sports on a spectrum

To contextualise their findings, the team plotted the outcomes of each fantasy sport on a spectrum of luck versus skill. Interestingly, both real and virtual baseball and basketball leaned more towards skill, compared to hockey and football, which had a stronger element of luck.

This study’s findings offer valuable insights not only for fantasy sports enthusiasts but also for the legal and judicial system, providing a quantitative analysis of where fantasy sports sit on the skill/luck spectrum. However, one key takeaway remains: even with a strong emphasis on skill, there’s always a sprinkle of luck involved in the outcome of any game, fantasy or otherwise.

Navigating through the world of fantasy sports: Leveraging skill over luck

One could argue that the study doesn’t offer any concrete strategies for improving your fantasy game performance. After all, it’s not like you can suddenly master the statistical analysis or predict the impact of unpredictable weather conditions on players’ performance. Yet, what this research does provide is a renewed sense of confidence in the skills you bring to the table when participating in fantasy sports.

In light of the findings, one should view participation in fantasy sports as a dynamic exercise of applied skills rather than a game of chance. You can take pride in your victories, knowing they resulted from your skillful selection and management of your virtual team rather than random luck.

And even if you can’t leverage these insights to assemble a superior sports team, you can certainly use them to boast about your expertise the next time you find yourself at the top of your league’s standings.

To conclude, whether you’re a seasoned player or a newbie testing the waters, it’s your skill that will most likely catapult you to the top in the world of fantasy sports. So, buckle up, delve into the statistics, keep track of player performance, and rely on your strategy to win the game. Remember, your victories are not flukes but a reflection of your tact and strategy, sprinkled with a dash of luck. The MIT study has spoken – fantasy sports are, indeed, a game of skill.

Vey Law

Vey Law is a reporter at Breakthrough.

Latest from Blog